|
"The challenge was to teach grade
ten students about Canadian sovereignty without putting them
to sleep" ~ High School Social Studies Teacher
As hard as it is to imagine, there are some young high school
students who are not as passionate about Canadian history
as their teachers. This study was developed to help address
this situation. Through the assistance of modern technology,
a Calgary teacher was able to enlist the creative geniuses
behind The
Canada Show to work with her students. Ryan Gladstone
and Bruce Horak from Monster
Theatre directed the performances of students in Calgary,
long distance from Toronto, as these young people created
their own production of The Sovereignty
Show.
The Inquiry study itself was designed by a teacher from the
National Sports School in collaboration with the Galileo Educational
Network using the web based environment io
(Inquiry Online).
The following short video excerpts present the story of this
inquiry into Canada’s sovereignty:
1.
According to Hargreaves (2003) the basic "grammar" of teaching and learning persists in high schools. “Most teachers teach as they have for generations – from the front of the classroom; through lecturing, seat work, and question-and-answer methods: and in separate classes of children of the same age, evaluated by standard paper-and-pencil methods” (p. 12).
When students were asked to describe their typical experience of school they provided the following accounts: "It’s just like dates straight out of the textbook. You would just cram it into your brain and as soon as the test was over it would be like gone. We would just read out of a textbook … textbook … textbook." |
| |
2.
"She’s got her science book so she finds the key word and flips through it; finds the word that fits and fills it in. She’s not reading anything. And I go, "what are you doing?" and she says, 'I just have to fill in this worksheet' and she’s an 80% student! ~ high school teacher" |
| |
|
3.
"I find io is easier. I can do it much faster now because I don’t need to read everything and can just focus on one section. I’ve done one before so I can even take a shell and change it and adapt it." |
| |
4.
"I have to teach students about
Canadian sovereignty which is always a challenge so
that they don’t fall asleep. In January I saw
The
Canada Show - Canadian history in an hour
without all the boring bits. And I decided to do it
with my kids…" (excerpt from The
Canada Show produced by Monster
Theatre)
|
| |
|
5.
"We did three telephone conferences
(with Ryan from Monster
Theatre) and then they actually rehearsed on live
video and it was fabulous."
|
| |
6.
"They were acting and they got tips from Ryan Gladstone and his colleague Bruce. It’s amazing once you get used to the technology it’s like they’re in the same room. And of course the kids respond to it." |
| |
7.
(Bruce directing) "The DEW line is the early defense system right? So if we’re looking at spy vs. spy you have the white spy representing the west and you’ve got the black spy representing the east which is great. Bring in the iron curtain and pull in Canada to bring it back to Canadian sovereignty. Will that work?" |
| |
8.
"When teachers talk about inquiry
they talk about catching the ones that are about to
drop out. The beauty of inquiry is that there is something
– an entry point for everybody. And the biggest
surprise for me were the girls: The really bright, gifted
girls who sit there and put up with all the nonsense
in schools. They put up with the boredom; they put up
with not being challenged; and here they just take off.
They loved it! They just go with it and the understanding
that they come up with is amazing. Inquiry has something
for everybody."
|
| |
9.
(Student pitching her idea for how
to represent the Quebec Referendum) "So I had this
idea of two people fighting over the TV remote control
to represent English and French Canada during the referendum."
|
| |
10.
"Look at the problems that the world faces today. We don’t need people who can memorize facts and score 100% on a multiple choice test. We need people who are critical thinkers; who know when they have a problem they have the tools to get out of it and investigate it and come up with some answers. Change is absolutely necessary!"
Hargreaves (2003) would agree with this assessment and further asserts that if we want to cultivate this type of thinking in our students we must invest in the kind of "professional support in which highly skilled teachers are able to generate creativity and ingenuity among their students by experiencing creativity and flexibility themselves in how they are treated and mentored as knowledge-society professionals" (p.2). |
| |
11.
As a society we must decide on the kind of learning that will serve students best in a knowledge era. Hargreaves (2002) asserts industrial schooling practices that emphasize standardization are "soulless" and stifle the creativity and intellectual growth of young people. In contrast, learning environments that require students to explore multiple solutions to problems cultivate ingenuity and help to advance our collective intelligence.
(Devon outlines his idea for representing the Cold War
using a Spy vs. Spy analogy. This example of knowledge
building took place during an audio conference with
Ryan Gladstone from Monster
Theatre.)
|
| |
12.
"The proof really came when
I gave them a position paper and those papers came in.
The discussion was at a much deeper level than what
grade ten students had done previously. The topics were
actually more challenging too." ~ high school Social
Studies teacher
|
| |
13.
(Scene from The
Canada Show - Students receive advice during
an audio conference about researching their topics)
"First of all what you want
to do is sit down and take a look at all the ideas that
you have and don’t censor anything and see what
it is that has inspired you so far. Because if something
has inspired you, you end up with a bunch of ideas and
I can hear you on this end of the phone across the country
when something inspires you because you all jump into
the conversation and there’s this whispering.
So take a look at everything you have written and all
the ideas that you have come up with and as a group
decide what it is about Canadian Sovereignty that you
want to say. Because only when you know what the ending
is will you know what the story is. So, how should we
start this?" Ryan Gladstone from Monster
Theatre
|
|